Beehiiv vs Substack (2025): Which Newsletter Platform Wins?
Substack made newsletters cool. Beehiiv wants to be what Substack should have been. Here's the honest comparison.
Tools mentioned
The biggest difference: economics
Substack takes 10% of your paid subscription revenue — forever. Beehiiv charges a flat monthly fee and takes 0% of your revenue on paid plans.
At 500 paying subscribers at $10/month, Substack takes $500/month. Beehiiv takes $0 of your subscription revenue (just their $39/month platform fee). That's $461/month difference. Over a year: $5,532 more in your pocket with Beehiiv.
Growth tools
Beehiiv has a native referral program and the Boosts ad network — you get paid when someone subscribes to your newsletter through another newsletter. No equivalent exists on Substack.
Substack has the 'Notes' social feed and recommendation network, which can drive organic growth between Substack writers. If you write about topics popular on Substack's platform (politics, finance, tech commentary), the recommendation network can be powerful.
Design control
Beehiiv gives you significantly more design control — custom domains, branded landing pages, custom fonts, and a slick web app for readers to browse your archive.
Substack newsletters all look similar, which is partially a brand choice (clean and editorial) but limits your ability to build a distinct identity. If brand matters to you, Beehiiv wins.
Analytics
Beehiiv's analytics dashboard is substantially better — detailed open rate tracking, click tracking by link, subscriber acquisition sources, revenue analytics, and A/B testing on subject lines.
Substack's analytics are basic: open rate, total subscribers, subscriber growth. Good enough if you just want to know what's working, but limiting if you want to optimize.
Which to pick
Start on Beehiiv if you're building a newsletter as a business — you want maximum revenue, growth tools, and brand control. The free plan is generous and the economics favor you as you scale.
Substack works well if you're a writer first, want the simplest possible setup, and want to tap into Substack's network effects in popular content categories. But understand the 10% tax on revenue is expensive long-term.
Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps keep BuildrGuide free. We only recommend tools we genuinely think are worth using.